Turkey’s post-coup crackdown hits ‘Gulen schools’ worldwide

Pupils at one of the Gulen linked schools in the Kyrgyz capital Bishkek are taught in Kyrgyz, English and Turkish
Image captionPupils at one of the Gulen linked schools in Kyrgyzstan are taught in Kyrgyz, English and Turkish

“I think it’s really sad and wrong they think we’re terrorists, because we’re not,” says Chilla, a bright and articulate sixth-former at the elite Kharisma Bangsa high school near Jakarta, Indonesia’s capital.

Until mid-July, her main worry was getting the right grades for medical school.

Now Chilla and her fellow pupils are faced with Turkish accusations that their school has links to a terrorist organisation.

Kharisma Bangsa school is one of hundreds across the world that Turkey wants to shut down because they have links to a US-based cleric, Fethullah Gulen.

The cleric is held responsible by the Ankara government for the failed July coup in which more than 270 people died.

And Turkey argues the schools are part of a strategy to undermine the state.

But pupils, teachers and parents interviewed in several countries say they have no links to suspicious activities.

Media caption‘Gulen’ schools reject Turkey subversion claim

Turkey looks to close Gulen schools

Who are the Gulenists?

Who is Fethullah Gulen?

Turkey coup: Who was behind Turkey coup attempt?

Turkish people climb on a tank attempting to stop the coup attempt in the early morning of July 16th in AnkaraImage copyrightAP
Image captionResidents tried to stop tanks rolling into Ankara during the attempted coup, which was blamed on Fethullah Gulen

Kharisma Bangsa is one of nine Indonesian schools Ankara says should be shut down because of their alleged ties to Fethullah Gulen.

Secretive network or loosely linked?

Turkey says the schools are part of a vast and secretive network which the Gulen movement has used to build a powerbase and infiltrate state institutions.

Accusations have been levelled against schools with Turkish connections in more than a dozen countries, from Germany to Afghanistan, leaving thousands of children facing uncertainty over their education.

Supporters of the schools say they are no more than a loose affiliation of institutions that share common values and are committed to academic excellence.

From extensive interviews with BBC World Service across 10 countries in three continents, it is clear that the schools have much in common but operate quite differently.

But all are feeling the pressure.

What is a Gulen school?

There is no common brand name for the schools.

Turkey has demanded the extradition of Fethullah Gulen from the US where he lives in exileImage copyrightAP
Image captionTurkey has demanded the extradition of Fethullah Gulen from the US where he lives in exile

In Pakistan they are called “Pak-Turk Lycees”, in Kyrgyzstan they are known as “Sebat” (Persistence) schools, and in Kenya, “Light Academies”.

Most were set up as partnerships between Turkish and local businesses and organisations, but in many countries like Indonesia and Kyrgyzstan, the Turkish partners are no longer directly involved.

Local and Turkish partners say they’re admirers of Fethullah Gulen, but not connected to him formally.

“A Gulen school, business or newspaper is generally unofficially labelled as such, because the owner or manager considers Fethullah Gulen as a spiritual leader or source of inspiration,” says Turkish academic Bayram Balci.

Alp Aslandogan, who speaks on behalf of Gulen-associated schools in the United States, says there are numerous social networks within the movement. “The schools which are seen as affiliated with the movement were started by people who belong to these networks.”

School focus on discipline

Followers of Fethullah Gulen often refer to their movement by the name Hizmet (service), and the schools all share the same ethics.

“The teachers put emphasis on character-building, morals, and discipline,” says Rosi, the mother of a pupil at Kharisma Bangsa.

Maxim Urazaev, a former student at the Turkish Tatar Lycee in Kazan, in Russia, remembers the strict discipline
Image captionMaxim Urazaev, a former student at the Turkish Tatar Lycee in Kazan, in Russia, remembers the strict discipline

There’s also a strong focus on teaching science.

From Nairobi to Kandahar, school websites show pupils in smart uniforms, studying in well-equipped science labs or computer rooms.

“The children study every day until 3pm, then they have additional classes, activity clubs, and homework,” says Baktigul, whose daughter attends a Turkish school in Kyrgyzstan. “At 9pm they all sit down to have tea, and at 10pm it’s bedtime.”

For Maxim Urazaev, who graduated from a Turkish lycee in the Russian city of Kazan in 2009 the experience was “tougher than being in the army”.

How close to Gulen himself?

Head teachers have told the BBC the schools are not part of a formal structure.

The head of Kyrgyzstan’s 21 Sebat schools, Nurlan Kudaberdiev, says they are all connected to Fethullah Gulen informally because the schools were his idea. “But there’s no direct influence or financing from his side any more,” he insists.

The head of the Sebat Persistence schools in Kyrgyzstan, Nurlan Kudaberdiev, says there are no direct links to Fethullah Gulen now
Image captionNurlan Kudaberdiev says schools in Kyrgystan have no direct links to Fethullah Gulen now
Zainal, a student at a Sebat school in Bishkek hopes to study medicine abroad when she graduates
Image captionZainal, a Kyrgyz student in Bishkek, hopes to study medicine abroad when she graduates

Long before the Turkish government tried to shut the schools down, other countries took action of their own amid suspicion of the network’s foreign links.

In 2000, Uzbekistan shut down all Gulen-associated schools operating there, and similar steps were taken in Russia, where only seven remain of the 50 schools that used to operate until 2008. All are now firmly under Education Ministry supervision in the Turkic-speaking Muslim region of Tatarstan.

Are they secular or religious?

The schools describe themselves as secular, promoting tolerance and interfaith dialogue.

“In my five years at the school I never once saw a Koran or a Bible,” says Maxim Urazaev, from Kazan.

But in Russia and elsewhere schools have been accused of running extra-curricular and secret, religious study groups.

Many former Soviet countries are deeply suspicious of religious activity beyond state control.

A former teacher in Tatarstan rejected the idea of “secret gatherings” but told the BBC that pupils who wanted to could pray with their teachers and talk to them about religion.

In Kenya, former students and teachers showed us books by Fethullah Gulen that they had been given.

In Kyrgyzstan, 15-year-old Zainal said pupils were sometimes shown videos about Islam.

But her mother, Bakhtigul, said she was satisfied it was not a problem. “I even checked the books in their library to see if they had any Gulen literature or suspicious books, but there was nothing.”

How Gulen schools spread

Gulen-affiliated schools have existed in Turkey since the 1970s and only expanded into a truly global phenomenon in the past 20 years.

That expansion came as Fethullah Gulen grew closer to Recep Tayyip Erdogan, whose Islamist-rooted AK Party swept to victory in 2002.

The Turkish government used to support the Gulen schools; here former Turkish president Abdullah Gul attends the opening of the Light Academy in Nairobi in 2008
Image captionThe Turkish government used to support the Gulen schools; here former Turkish president Abdullah Gul attends the opening of the Light Academy in Nairobi in 2009

By teaching Turkish and promoting Turkish culture the schools helped to reinforce Turkey’s position and influence across the former Soviet Union, the Far East and into Africa.

In 2015 Turkey invested $6.2bn (£4.7bn; €5.5bn) across Africa.

Somalia became a flagship for Turkish aid and investment, with three Gulen-linked schools catering for more than 1,000 children.

Opportunities and connections

Although the schools are fee-paying and attract the children of the elite, they also offer scholarships to poorer families.

In Pakistan up to a quarter of children are on scholarships, in Afghanistan it is nearly 30%.

Quite apart from the lure of a good education, the schools also offer an opportunity to travel by way of inter-school competitions known as “Olympiads”.

A banner at a school in Indonesia
Image captionA banner at a Jakarta school praises a pupil’s success in a chemistry competition in Georgia

Star pupils from Kabul have competed in maths and Turkish-language competitions in Uganda, while children from Mogadishu have tested their skills in Kazakhstan.

The schools say the competitions are a way of making a global network of friends.

But Turkey argues they enable a movement responsible for a deadly coup attempt to continue recruiting new members worldwide.


Which countries have agreed to Turkey’s school closure demands?

  • All three schools in Somalia were summarily shut down and the Turkish teaching staff sent home. They have now reopened under new management, with Somali teachers and Turkish embassy funding
  • In Azerbaijan, the prestigious Gulen-associated Qafqaz university, is now under new government-controlled management
  • But in Indonesia , the education minister visited Kharisma Bangsa school and decided he was happy with the running of the school and claims of terror links were “not true”
  • In Kyrgyzstan, President Almazbek Atambayev insisted the schools were “high quality educational establishments and we need them”
  • The authorities in Kenya and Nigeria also resisted Turkish pressure
  • In Pakistan 23 Turkish teachers have been sacked. Education Minister Muhammed Baligh ur Rahman said if Turkey had doubts about the teachers, then Pakistan “might not be able to let them continue”

Thousands of children and their families have been left feeling vulnerable, and for many their future at the Gulen schools is unclear.

Jakarta schoolgirl Chilla
Image captionJakarta schoolgirl Chilla is aiming to get into medical school

“I’ve been here for eleven years,” says Musukan, a sixth former at the Pak-Turk school in Islamabad. “This was the best time of my life. We love it here.”

“If Turkey really has problems, don’t involve us,” says Salwa, an Indonesian sixth former. “We’re only here to study and to pursue our dreams.”

Jerome Wirawan, Olga Ivshina and Iram Abbasi contributed to this report. 


Gulen schools around the world

INTERACTIVE

Netherlands

Germany

Turkey

Nigeria

Tanzania

Kenya

Somalia

Iraq

Azerbaijan

Kyrgyzstan

Tajikistan

Afghanistan

Pakistan

Cambodia

Thailand

Indonesia

Russia

  • ×

  • Netherlands

    ×

    Number of Gulen-associated schools: 11

    Status: all schools still open, however a Turkish news agency published list of people and organisations in the Netherlands which it said had links to Fetullah Gulen

  • Germany

    ×

    Number of Gulen-associated schools: 14

    Status: all schools still open, however Turkish officials have requested the schools be examined

  • Turkey

    ×

    Number of Gulen-associated schools: 1,032 (plus 15 universities)

    Number of students: 135,000 (plus 65,000 in universities)

    Status: all schools and universities shut down. Students allocated to other schools and colleges

  • Nigeria

    ×

    Number of Gulen-associated schools: 17 (plus one university)

    Number of students: 4,700 (17% on scholarships)

    Status: all still open despite Turkish calls to close them. However, they have changed their names to remove any reference to Turkey

  • Tanzania

    ×

    Number of Gulen-associated schools: 10

    Status: no news of schools being closed, however the Turkish embassy published a letter on its Facebook page calling for the schools to be closed down

  • Kenya

    ×

    Number of Gulen-associated schools: seven (four in Nairobi, two in Mombasa and one in Malindi)

    Number of students: 2,000

    Status: all schools still open, however Turkey is calling for them to be closed

  • Somalia

    ×

    Number of Gulen-associated schools: three

    Number of students: 1,000

    Status: all schools shut down after coup and Turkish teachers sent home. Now reopened under new management with Somali teachers

  • Iraq

    ×

    Number of Gulen-associated schools: 37 in Iraqi Kurdistan (includes primary and high schools and a university)

    Number of students: 40,000

    Status: management of entire network has been replaced following Turkish government request

  • ×

  • ×

  • ×

  • ×

  • ×

  • ×

  • ×

  • ×

  • ×

  • ×

  • Azerbaijan

    ×

    Number of Gulen-associated schools: 11 (plus one university)

    Status: schools taken over by education ministry in 2014. University shut and reopened under new management after July 2016

  • Kyrgyzstan

    ×

    Number of Gulen-associated schools: 21

    Number of students: 12,500

    Status: schools still open after government rejects Turkish calls to close them

  • Tajikistan

    ×

    Number of Gulen-associated schools: 6 schools in 4 main cities

    Status: taken over by the government and rebranded Schools for Gifted children in 2015

  • Afghanistan

    ×

    Number of Gulen-associated schools: 20

    Number of students: 8,000 (30% of students on scholarships)

    Status: all schools still open, no official call for closure but reports of deep concern from parents

  • Pakistan

    ×

    Number of Gulen-associated schools: 28

    Number of students: 11,000 (one quarter on scholarships)

    Status: 23 Turkish teachers have been removed after Turkish call for schools to be closed

  • Cambodia

    ×

    Number of Gulen-associated schools: three (plus one university)

    Status: all schools open despite call from Turkish ambassador to Cambodia to shut them down

  • Thailand

    ×

    Number of Gulen-associated schools: four

    Number of students: 2,000

    Status: all schools still open but Turkish embassy calling for them to close

  • Indonesia

    ×

    Number of Gulen-associated schools: nine

    Number of students: 2,000

    Status: all schools still open after government rejects Turkish call for them to be closed

  • Russia

    ×

    Number of Gulen-associated schools: seven

    Status: schools now operating under Education Ministry management in Tatarstan. Forty three shut down across the country in 2008

 

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s